|
IV. Studies
Regarding the Detoxification Program Developed by L. Ron
Hubbard
A. Safety of the
Program
An initial study of 103
individuals demonstrated the safety of this program. Medical complications
associated with the program occurred in less than 3% of the individuals and
were minor in nature. There was one case of pneumonia, one of ear infection,
and one case of diarrhea during the approximately 3 weeks of program delivery.
Reductions in blood pressure and cholesterol were benefits of the program. The
program also resulted in improvements in psychological test scores.
(52)
This program is designed to
mobilize and eliminate fat-stored chemicals. During any such program in which
xenobiotics are deliberately mobilized from fat stores, it is important that
elimination keep pace with this mobilization process. Otherwise it is possible
that mobilization will result in heightened blood concentrations of the
mobilized compounds.
Blood levels of chemicals were
monitored in a study of electrical workers conducted by Schnare & Robinson
(53). They showed that blood levels of both PCBs and pesticides were fairly
consistent over the course of treatment. Thus, elimination of compounds
appeared to keep pace with their mobilization during this study.
B. Results of
Detoxification
The detoxification method
developed by Hubbard has been shown to reduce levels of several fat-stored
chemicals. Studies of this method have focused on individuals who have
accumulated fat-soluble compounds through either occupational or environmental
exposure.
In 1983, Roehm reported reductions
in DDE and PCBs and clearing of symptoms in a Vietnam vet with a range of
symptoms (54).
A 1984 study demonstrated
statistically significant reductions of from 10.1 to 65.9 percent for sixteen
fat-stored compounds. The compounds tested included polychlorinated biphenyls
(PCBs), polybrominated biphenyls (PBBs) and chlorinated pesticides. The study
population had been specifically exposed to PBBs approximately 10 years prior
to treatment. Reductions in
PBBs were 58.7 percent (p<0.O5)
when treated with Hubbard's method. (55) According to independent evaluation,
the chemical levels for PBBs had not reduced during the five years prior to
treatment (56).
In a controlled study, electrical
workers exposed to hexachlorobenzene (HCB), PCBs and other compounds, were
treated with the Hubbard method. Statistically significant reductions of 30%
for HCB and 16% for PCBs were observed. These reductions were stable at
follow-up observations 3 months subsequent to treatment (53).
Further documentation of PCB
reduction was reported in the case of a female factory worker from Yugoslavia.
Her excessive PCB levels (102 mg/Kg in adipose and 512 ug/L in serum
approximately 50 times higher than the general population) were reduced by 63%
in adipose and 49% in serum following treatment. In addition, a spontaneous
breast discharge containing PCBs ceased during treatment. This woman's symptoms
also improved over the course of treatment. (38)
Improvements in this woman led to
a controlled study of a group of male co-workers. Again, reductions in PCB
levels were observed and improvements in symptoms noted for the group treated
with the method developed by Hubbard . (57,58)
As the number of toxic chemicals
in the workplace increases, it is sometimes difficult to identify the exact
nature of a toxicant. Such was the case for a woman exposed to both the
residues trapped in filters from the exhaust stacks of an oil-fired electrical
generator and the contaminated water used to clean these filters. She became
ill following 6 months of such exposure and was unable to work. During
treatment with Hubbard's method a black substance began oozing from her pores.
This abated late in treatment. Both her objective and subjective complaints
were reduced following treatment and she was able to return to work.
(59)
Firefighters are often exposed to
toxic compounds in the course of their work. Such was the case for a group of
firefighters responding to a fire involving transformers filled with PCBs.
Several of these men became ill following the fire.
Neurophysiological and
neuro-psychological tests were conducted on 14 of these firefighters 6 months
after the fire. This battery of 22 tests demonstrated that the firefighters who
had been involved with the fire were significantly impaired in both memory and
cognitive functions when compared to coworkers from the same department who had
not participated in fighting this fire. (Scores for 13 of the 22 tests were
significantly worse in the exposed firefighters.)
Following treatment with the
detoxification method developed by Hubbard, significant improvements in 6 of
the 13 tests originally showing impairment were noted. (60)
These firefighters were also
tested for peripheral nerve damage. Five of the seventeen firefighters tested
showed significant peripheral neuropathy. All showed improvement following
treatment with Hubbard's method, with two of the five returning to normal
range. (61)
Many people have experienced
adverse health effects after exposure to compounds whose identity is unknown.
The detoxification program has been shown effective in alleviating symptoms in
such patients. In one study, the selected patient population reported symptom
profiles prior to treatment that were in alignment with chemically exposed
individuals reported by other authors (not statistically different). Following
treatment, their symptom profiles had improved significantly and were now not
significantly different from a healthy population. (62) » Continued » Table of contents |